All Orthopedic Surgery

Top-Rated Orthopedic Surgery in Columbus, OH

40 physicians

40 orthopedic surgery surgeons practicing in Columbus — with clinical reviews from the OR insiders who work with them. Find the right surgeon, or share your own experience to help patients and colleagues.

Dr. John Alexander

Orthopedic Surgery

Columbus, OH

The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center

No reviews yet — be the first

Dr. Meredith Arensman

Orthopedic Surgery

Columbus, OH

Columbus Va Ambulatory Care Center

No reviews yet — be the first

Dr. Hisham Awan

Orthopedic Surgery

Columbus, OH

The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center

No reviews yet — be the first

Dr. Jeffrey Backes

Orthopedic Surgery

Columbus, OH

Orthopedic One

No reviews yet — be the first

Dr. William Barker

Orthopedic Surgery

Columbus, OH

Orthopedic One

No reviews yet — be the first

Dr. Matthew Beal

Orthopedic Surgery

Columbus, OH

The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center

No reviews yet — be the first

Dr. Gregory Bellisari

Orthopedic Surgery

Columbus, OH

Orthopedic One

No reviews yet — be the first

Dr. Matthew Beran

Orthopedic Surgery

Columbus, OH

Nationwide Children's Hospital

No reviews yet — be the first

Dr. Brent Bickel

Orthopedic Surgery

Columbus, OH

Orthopedic One

No reviews yet — be the first

Dr. Julie Bishop

Orthopedic Surgery

Columbus, OH

The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center

No reviews yet — be the first

Dr. Rahul Biyani

Orthopedic Surgery

Columbus, OH

Ohiohealth Riverside Methodist Hospital And Emergency Department

No reviews yet — be the first

Dr. Ryan Blackwell

Orthopedic Surgery

Columbus, OH

Orthopedic One

No reviews yet — be the first

Dr. Thomas Boniface

Orthopedic Surgery

Columbus, OH

Columbus Va Ambulatory Care Center

No reviews yet — be the first

Dr. William Burgette

Orthopedic Surgery

Columbus, OH

Orthopedic One

No reviews yet — be the first

Dr. Andrew Campbell

Orthopedic Surgery

Columbus, OH

Ohiohealth Riverside Methodist Hospital And Emergency Department

No reviews yet — be the first

Dr. Joaquin Castaneda

Orthopedic Surgery

Columbus, OH

Ohiohealth Grant Medical Center And Emergency Department

No reviews yet — be the first

Dr. Bryan Chambers

Orthopedic Surgery

Columbus, OH

Orthopedic One

No reviews yet — be the first

Dr. Douglas Chonko

Orthopedic Surgery

Columbus, OH

The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center

No reviews yet — be the first

Dr. Brian Cohen

Orthopedic Surgery

Columbus, OH

Ohiohealth Grant Medical Center And Emergency Department

No reviews yet — be the first

Dr. Angela Collins

Orthopedic Surgery

Columbus, OH

The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center

No reviews yet — be the first

What to Look For in a Orthopedic Surgery Surgeon

Orthopedic surgery covers an enormous range of procedures — joint replacements, sports-medicine arthroscopy, spine work, fracture fixation, and complex reconstruction. Many orthopedic surgeons sub-specialize, so a hip and knee replacement expert is not necessarily the right choice for a rotator cuff repair or a pediatric scoliosis case. The first thing to confirm is that a surgeon performs your specific procedure regularly.

Beyond credentials and fellowship training, the OR nurses, surgical techs, and device representatives who scrub in on these cases see what patients never do: how precisely a surgeon handles tissue, how calm they stay during a difficult reconstruction, and how well they lead the team when an implant does not seat as planned. Those firsthand observations are exactly what the Insight Score on Physician Signal captures.

When comparing orthopedic surgeons, weigh procedure-specific volume, comfort with the implant systems and instrumentation your case requires, and the consistency of their technique across cases. A surgeon who is respected by the team that works beside them every day is a strong signal of quality.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many orthopedic surgery physicians are listed in Columbus, OH?

There are 40 orthopedic surgery physicians practicing in Columbus, OH listed on Physician Signal, ranked by clinical reviews from verified healthcare professionals who have worked with them in the operating room.

How are orthopedic surgery surgeons in Columbus rated?

Each surgeon's Insight Score is the average of six clinical dimensions rated anonymously by the OR nurses, surgical techs, device reps, and fellow surgeons who work alongside them. The list is sorted to surface the most-reviewed physicians in Columbus first.

How do I choose the right orthopedic surgeon?

Start by confirming the surgeon performs your specific procedure regularly and is fellowship-trained in the relevant sub-specialty. Then look at how they are rated by the OR staff and device reps who work alongside them — those peers see surgical skill and decision-making patients cannot observe.

What does the Insight Score measure for orthopedic surgeons?

The Insight Score is the average of six clinical dimensions — surgical skill, bedside manner, professionalism, openness to new technology, staff collaboration, and clinical outcomes — rated anonymously by verified healthcare professionals who have worked with that surgeon in the operating room.

Worked with one of these surgeons? Leave a Signal.

Surgeons, OR nurses, surgical techs, and device reps in Columbus, OH — your honest, anonymous review helps the next team know what to expect, and gives patients clinical insight they cannot get anywhere else. 100% anonymous. Takes 3 minutes.

Ghost Identity protected

·

No login required

·

We never share who reviewed